We Have Never Been Middle Class
https://www.gofundme.com/red-may-2020-capitalism-or-life
Work hard, play by the rules, get ahead. You’ve heard that sermon from Obama, from Elizabeth Warren, maybe even internalized the unstated corollary. If you don’t make it, schmuck, it’s your own fault. Our panelists see it differently. Promises of social mobility in neoliberal capitalist America are empty. Working-class children without college degrees, as Jennifer Silva has shown, have no shot at the union jobs their parents or grandparents had, and struggle to manage their pain. Students form what Gary Roth calls an educated underclass. The so-called professional-managerial class, which saw itself as a neutral arbiter between Capital and Labor, as Gabriel Winant has noted, is decomposing into a few winners and an indebted, downwardly mobile majority. And Hadas Weiss argues that the so-often-invoked category of ‘the middle class’ itself is nothing more than an ideology, a fantasy produced by capitalism which instills the belief that anyone can ascend or rise entirely by his or her own efforts. Now — after the onslaught of Covid-19 and the steps taken to isolate it — economists are predicting a 30% unemployment rate, larger than the Great Depression. How will the already-frayed ideology of the American Dream fare under circumstances that demand resources far beyond individual merit? Will the loose conception of society as being composed of a broad, middle strata, surrounded by the fortunate rich and the unfortunate poor, give way to a relational picture of class, one that maps lines of class struggle more accurately and reveals whose foot is on whose head? Red May welcomes four actual social scientists to figure things out.
Gary Roth, Hadas Weiss, Gabriel Winant, Jennifer Silva, Philip Wohlstetter (mod)